Carl Fonticella | November 19, 2026
General McLane senior wide receiver Donny Burke had just one catch in the District 10 Class 4A Championship game on November 13, 2026. However, you only need one moment to completely change a game, and his catch is a moment that will go down in both school and District 10 football history.
His catch came in a situation kids dream of growing up. Down 31-28 with 26 seconds on the clock, the Lancers were facing 4th and 10 on their opponent’s 10 yard line. Burke lined up on the right side of the line as a tight end and at the snap, junior WR Gabe Montroy went in motion from the left to the right side of the line, and senior QB Josh Caro faked the handoff to senior Graedy Sharp after getting the snap.
Looking to the end zone, Caro threw the ball to Burke who had completed his route to the back right corner of the end zone. Despite being double-covered, he outjumped both defenders and came down with the catch to give the Lancers an improbable win over rivals Cathedral Prep after being down 10 with just 9 and a half minutes remaining in the 4th quarter.
Looking back at the play, Burke says, “I just felt like in that moment, I knew I had an opportunity to make a play, and I was really grateful that I had that opportunity.”

Both General McLane and Cathedral Prep had called timeouts before the play, but according to Caro, the fact that Prep called the second timeout after seeing GM come back out in an offensive formation did nothing to change the game plan.
“We always kind of knew we had to get the ball to like one of our best receivers,” Caro said in an interview on Wednesday. “So, you know, after Prep’s timeout, we knew that they’re kind of scheming our offensive formation that we came out with, but our vision stayed the same, and we knew we had to get the job done.”
The win gave the Lancers their 2nd District 10 title in 3 years and their 3rd straight win over the Cathedral Prep Ramblers. GM came away with a 40-27 win during the regular season on October 9th and experienced a thrilling 28-14 win over Prep last year.
Before that, however, McLane had seen just 1 win in 16 previous games, and were outscored 641-196 across those 16 games.
The General McLane Lancers (then Edinboro High) and Cathedral Prep Ramblers first played in 1928, a 7-6 win in favor of the Ramblers. They then played each other 6 more times through 2007, and even though General McLane went on a memorable state title-winning run in 2006, that year’s 13-2 record included a loss to Cathedral Prep.
Don’t let the lopsided record fool you – this is a rivalry, and a fierce one at that.
The matchup truly became a rivalry (and quickly intensified) in December 2011. Not due to a coaching change, or a switch between the two schools by a player, but all thanks to an email.
And not even an email that had anything to do with football.
That month saw a Prep faculty member send out a school-wide email in which he called out the Prep student body over what he deemed was subpar school spirit at a basketball game between the two schools, and in the email included these now infamous words.
The email, intended for internal eyes at Cathedral Prep only, went public.
And viral.
Not only did Erie-area media report on it, but the story was picked up by (among others) Forbes, Yahoo Sports, The Times Leader in Eastern PA, Deadspin, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and the Philadelphia Inquirer.
15 years on, those in Edinboro and those associated with General McLane haven’t forgotten those words.
Pat Hargest is the long-time owner of the Edinboro Hotel Bar, a beloved local landmark in the college town of the same name. Edinboro is just a few miles down the road from General McLane High School and the town is part of the GM school district. Many McLane graduates go on to study at PennWest Edinboro, and the colors of red and white are shared by both schools.
“I grew up here. I’m a McLane graduate, I went to Edinboro and am an Edinboro graduate as well, so I’m a lifelong community member. It was shocking to hear that come out [about the email], especially from someone who was an authority at Cathedral Prep,” says Hargest.
The email included much more (including calling GM “General McLame), but Lancer fans have remembered the “mayo sandwich” line ever since. Despite the email’s original intentions, words that were initially designed to hurt and mock those in Red and White are now used widespread in the community.
“We’ve had fun with it over the years – you called us this, we’re going to embrace it, we’re going to take this as a rallying cry,” Hargest says. “I respect their coaches and their players in all sports, and hopefully everyone understands it’s all in good fun.”
In the years after the email, Cathedral Prep saw unprecedented success as members in both District 10 and in the PIAA playoffs. The Ramblers went to Hershey and the state title game in 2012, 2015, 2016, 2017 and 2018, and went to the state semifinals in 2013. Head coach Mike Mischler and the team lifted the state championship trophy on 4 occasions, including a 3-peat from 2016-18 to go along with their championship in 2012.

Every year from 2012-2017 included the same result – a resounding win for Prep over General McLane. Throughout that time span, Cathedral Prep outscored GM 441-84, posting 2 shutouts and scoring more than 60 points on 4 occasions. To top it all off, Prep went on an incredible 81-4 run, winning 28 consecutive games on two separate occasions from 2012-13 and 2016-17.
However, since current GM head coach Marshall McCormick was promoted to lead the team in 2022, fortunes have changed for the Lancers in this matchup. Including Friday’s win, they now hold a 3-1 advantage over Prep in the last 4 games.
The upperclassmen on this Lancer team were the first in a generation to experience a win over Cathedral Prep with their 28-14 win last season, but they would not have been old enough to remember what happened immediately post-email. Don’t let their age fool you though, as every single member of the team (and members of the student body in the stands) could not have been more excited to experience not only that win, but Friday’s D10 championship win as well, as after the trophy presentation the entirety of the General McLane student section stormed the Fairview field to celebrate with the team.

Special t-shirts had been made for the game, and on them were images that would be eye-catching to those not familiar with the rivalry between the two schools. While many student sections agree on a specific theme for a game (beach, USA, neon, etc.), many in the GM crowd could be seen sporting white t-shirts with a Hellman’s mayonnaise jar on the front and back, and a very simple and clear message on the jar on the back.
“Beat Prep”
“Yeah, I think that was sick,” says senior TE Caiden Holler. “We had a plan to hand them out in school, and we handed a bunch of them out just for free to get guys going to the game, and it got a lot of students out there, and it’s definitely something that Prep probably noticed and found online everywhere. So it was definitely good.”
“I’ve seen the email, I’ve read the whole email. I think it’s pretty funny,” Burke added.
Every Lancer player, from the youth level to high school, is told stories of Drew Astorino, Dan and Ryan Skelton, Bobby Stauffer, Kelley Ponsoll and others on that 2006 state title winning team – and rest assured they’re also told stories of that email.
Senior QB Josh Caro took over the reins from his older brother Matt who led the team as quarterback last season, and for him, there is an added factor heading every game against Cathedral Prep.
“Through my family and through the older generations, it’s just definitely something that’s been big for them,” says Caro. “And [the email] gives us extra momentum going into that game, knowing that we’re playing for our community behind us, and not just our generation, but the generations that came before.”
This year’s team now sets their sights on another deep run in the PIAA State Playoffs, and it begins with a first round game against Clearfield. It’s a rematch of the first round of the 2024 state playoffs in which the Bison won 27-26 in dramatic fashion. Clearfield went ahead with under 2 minutes to go, and later blocked a GM field goal attempt with just 15 seconds remaining in the game.
Speaking after the District 10 win, McCormick said that the coaching staff’s memory of that field goal (along with yet another blocked field goal in last year’s District 10 championship loss to Oil City) played a part in the decision to go for it on 4th down against Cathedral Prep.
The Lancers were within touching distance of the school’s first state playoff win since that championship game win over Pottsville in 2006, and now look to reverse their fortunes from that November night two years ago.
In sports, it is common to get the chance to “re-do” something. Miss a free throw or a 3-pointer? There’s the potential for more in a game. Same goes with a misplaced pass in soccer or football, a fastball that doesn’t go exactly where you and your catcher wanted it to go, a lacrosse or hockey shot that clangs off the post instead of going in.
However, it is incredibly rare for sports to give you the same *exact* situation, especially after multiple seasons pass.
In 2024, General McLane were the District 10 champs. Clearfield were the District 8/9 champs after defeating Pittsburgh University Prep in a game in which their offense put up 34 points. In 2026, General McLane are District 10 champs – Clearfield are District 8/9 champs after defeating Pittsburgh University Prep and, you guessed it, scored 34 points.
In 2024, General McLane made the near 3-hour trip east to Clearfield. On Friday, they will make the exact same trip.
However, Clearfield came into the 2024 game riding the momentum of their own undefeated season. The Bison were 11-0, improving to 12-0 with the victory over the Lancers.
General McLane’s record heading into this Friday’s game? 11-0.
Hargest was asked to make a short ad for Lancer Link, the General McLane student production that live streams football games in addition to producing podcasts, showcasing student work, creating teacher spotlights and showing off life at the school.
Tune into the broadcast on Friday and you’ll see him at the counter at the Edinboro Hotel.
Making a mayonnaise sandwich.
